Past Its Prime: A Grown-Up's Guide to Cleaning, Storing, and Retiring Your Toys
Photo by Photo by Ibrahim Boran on Unsplash on Unsplash
Everybody has the drawer. Maybe it's a shoebox on a high shelf, maybe it's a canvas pouch behind the towels, maybe it's a sock. Inside, statistically, there is at least one item that has not been cleaned since the Obama administration and one item that no longer turns on.
This is the unglamorous half of owning nice things: the maintenance. Let's do it properly, because a well-kept product lasts years and a neglected one becomes a small biohazard with a motor.
First, Know What You Actually Own
Cleaning rules follow material, not marketing. Check the box or the product page and sort your collection into two buckets: porous and non-porous.
Non-porous (the easy ones): platinum-cure or medical-grade silicone, borosilicate glass, stainless steel, and hard ABS plastic. Bacteria can't sink in. These can be cleaned thoroughly and, in most cases, sterilized.
Porous (the high-maintenance ones): TPE, TPR, elastomer, PVC, and anything sold as "jelly" or "realistic skin." These absorb what they touch, and they can't be fully sterilized. They have a shorter working life by design.
And check the motor. Look for an IPX rating. IPX7 means it can survive a dunk. No rating at all means assume water is the enemy.
Cleaning Without Wrecking the Thing
The universal routine, which covers almost everything:
- Warm water, mild unscented soap. Fragrance and dyes are the usual culprits behind irritation complaints.
- Wash the whole surface, including seams and the base of the shaft where gunk hides.
- Rinse thoroughly — soap residue is a real irritant.
- Dry completely before storage. Air dry on a clean towel, then pat down. Moisture trapped in a pouch is how you get a smell you can't explain.
Now the variations.
- Non-motorized silicone, glass, or steel: boil for three to five minutes, or wipe with a 10% bleach solution and then wash with soap and water. Some silicone and glass is dishwasher-safe on the top rack — confirm with the manufacturer first, because coatings and seams vary.
- Motorized anything: never submerge unless it's rated for it. Wipe with a soapy cloth, wring it out, and keep water away from the charging port and any buttons. Check the O-ring seal at the base; a dried-out or nicked ring is how waterproof toys stop being waterproof.
- TPE and jelly: soap and water only. No boiling, no bleach, no alcohol. They'll degrade faster than you'd believe. Many people pair these with a condom for exactly this reason.
- Skip the alcohol wipes. They're fine on glass and steel, rough on silicone over time, and genuinely bad for TPE.
One rule that matters more than the rest: silicone lubricant will degrade silicone toys. It turns them tacky and eventually gummy. Use water-based lube on silicone toys. Silicone lube is great on glass, steel, and ABS.
Motor Care Is Just Battery Care
Most "broken" toys aren't broken. They're badly stored.
- Battery-powered: take the batteries out between uses. Leaking alkaline batteries have killed more good toys than any other cause, and corrosion is permanent.
- Rechargeable: if you're putting something away for a while, store it around half charge, not empty and not full. Top it up every two to three months.
- Don't live on the charger. Constant topping-off shortens lithium battery life.
- Heat is the enemy. Not the bathroom windowsill, not the car in July, not the shelf above the radiator.
- Weak vibration on a full charge means the motor is going, not the battery. That's your cue.
Storage That Respects Your Roommates, Your Kids, and Your Toys
A drawer is fine. A drawer done well is better.
- Breathable pouches, not Ziplocs. Cotton or satin bags let moisture escape. Plastic bags trap it.
- Don't let TPE touch silicone. Plasticizers migrate between materials and can literally melt a sticky patch into a neighboring toy. Separate bags, every time.
- Cool, dark, dry. A steamy bathroom is the worst room in the house for this.
- A lockable case solves a lot. A makeup train case, a small toolbox, or a hard-shell case with a luggage lock. It's not about shame — it's about not having to explain yourself to a niece who's looking for nail polish.
- Travel: pull the batteries, use a pouch, keep it in your carry-on rather than checked luggage. Nothing about a personal massager violates a TSA rule, and the agent has seen a thousand of them.
- Don't stack heavy things on top. Motors and seams don't love compression.
Five Signs It's Time to Say Goodbye
- Cracks, tears, or peeling coating. Any break in the surface of a porous item is a place bacteria move into and stay.
- A tacky surface that soap won't fix. That's material breakdown, not dirt.
- A smell or discoloration that comes back after washing. Same answer.
- Motor noise, rattle, or a charge that no longer holds. It's on its way out; replace on your schedule, not mid-scene.
- It's porous and it's had a year of regular use. TPE and jelly are consumables. Treat them that way.
And a sixth, the one nobody prints on a box: if you dread using it, or it doesn't fit your body the way it used to, that's a good enough reason. Bodies change. Products don't have to be broken to be done.
The $5 Novelty and the $150 Investment Are Not the Same Object
Here's the sustainability conversation, and it starts before the trash can.
A five-dollar jelly novelty is disposable by design. It'll go tacky, it'll crack, and it'll be landfill inside a year — after maybe a handful of uses. The most sustainable thing you can do with that category is not buy it. If you already own one and it's done, wrap it, put it in the trash, and never flush it. Nothing about a toy belongs in a toilet.
A well-made silicone piece is a different animal. Cared for properly, it can run a decade. Silicone isn't accepted in curbside recycling, but a growing number of brands run take-back or trade-in programs, and some specialty recyclers will accept clean silicone for reprocessing. Ask before you toss.
Rechargeable items with dead batteries are e-waste. Pull the battery if it's user-replaceable and take it to a household hazardous waste site or a battery drop-off; don't put a lithium cell in the kitchen bin.
And never donate a used product. Not to a thrift store, not to a friend, not to a buy-nothing group. That's not generosity, that's a biohazard with good intentions.
The Short Version
Wash it with unscented soap, dry it all the way, keep it out of the bathroom, bag it separately, pull the batteries, and let it go when the surface gives out. That's the whole religion. Your drawer will thank you, and so will future you.